Task 160: Cross-Episode Report Quality Review
完了 ← タスク一覧
Task 160: Cross-Episode Report Quality Review
Status: DONE
Motivation
Tasks 158-159 just added significant new content to the cross-episode report:
- Mass timeline visualization (uPlot chart, 2 scenarios)
- Cross-episode counterfactual analysis (4 alternative mission profiles)
This new content hasn't been reviewed. CLAUDE.md mandates external agent review for report quality.
Scope
- Review cross-episode.json for data integrity and analytical logic
- Check that mass timeline data matches episode calculations
- Verify counterfactual analysis numbers are consistent
- Check rendered HTML for layout/navigation issues
- Fix any issues found
Review Findings & Fixes
External Sonnet agent review identified 11 issues (3 critical, 3 significant, 5 quality).
Critical (Fixed)
- Timeline badge annotations wrong: T+527d/539d/562d → corrected to T+461d/468d/479d (matched the stated 479-day mission)
- Mass timeline chart had spurious third burn at EP1: Erroneous 125.7→83.4t drop removed from both Isp series. Chart now correctly shows only accel+decel for EP1 brachistochrone
- Chart description didn't state its analytical framework: Added explicit note that chart uses forward simulation from 299t initial mass with Enceladus refuel
Significant (Fixed)
- ΔV formula error: $\Delta V = 2d/t$ → corrected to $\Delta V = 4d/t$ (all numerical values were already correct)
- Probability estimates misrepresented as derived from sigma: Clarified these are subjective Bayesian estimates, not computed from the stated sigma values
- Isp=5×10⁶ s introduced without context: Added note explaining this represents optimistic D-He³ upper limit (16% of light speed)
Quality (Fixed)
- No series introduction: Added "シリーズ概要と本分析の前提" section explaining SOLAR LINE premise, crew, and the 48,000t mystery
- Margin chart mixed units: Y-axis label changed from "制約余裕率 (%)" to "マージン指標" with note about mixed units
- Daedalus Isp misclassification: Moved from 5×10⁵ s to 10⁶ s category (correct for D-He³ ICF design)
- Wrong source citation: Bussard & DeLauer (1958, fission) → Project Daedalus (BIS, 1978, D-He³ fusion)
- Counterfactual C undamaged ship: Added note about 65% thrust constraint in EP05
Dependencies
- Task 158 (mass timeline) DONE
- Task 159 (counterfactual analysis) DONE
- All episode analyses DONE